Mustard is Cheap! Why Make Your Own?

guinness-stout-mustardSuper Easy and Delicious Home Made Mustard

I recently ran across a really simple and wonderful recipe for those of you that like a really nice robust tasting mustard. I have nothing against traditional American “yellow” mustard, and I actually think it’s the perfect condiment for “dirty-water” hot dogs, and “razor” burgers (which also require a fat dollop of Heinz Ketchup, in my opinion).

But, this mustard is for the heartier meats, like Leberkäse, corned beef, or smoked ham. It’s heavenly on a pastrami or roast beef sandwich too. Additionally, it can be customized with added herbs and spices to focus its flavor toward a particular dish, with addition of honey, powdered rosemary, dill, or horseradish for example.

Read on for the recipe.




Guinness Stout Mustard

1/4 cup                yellow mustard seeds
1/4 cup                brown mustard seeds
3/4 cup               apple cider vinegar
1/3 cup                stout beer or smoked porter
2 teaspoons        sugar, or honey, or agave syrup, or dark molasses
1/2 teaspoon      liquid smoke (optional)

Mix all ingredients in a small plastic storage container or glass jar and allow to sit at room temperature for two days. Shake container occasionally.

Seeds Soaking
Seeds Soaking

Place mixture in blender or food processor and pulse on and off for about a minute until desired consistency has been reached.
Taste and add more sweetness or smoke flavor as desired. Refrigerate.


This mustard would typically be described as “hot” mustard, because of its bold, forward. spicy flavor, but it contains no turmeric, so it is a different kind of “spicy” than traditional yellow mustards. After it is all blenderized, take a small prep bowl and stir in other flavors that you want to experiment with. You will be surprised as to the variety of flavors you can coax from this simple recipe.

Mixed about 50/50 with a good hearty mayo, this makes a great sandwich spread too.

Adding the “liquid smoke” really punches up the flavor and I suggest you give it a try if you decide to make this. I bought my light and dark mustard seeds at the local “Sprouts” supermarket in the bulk aisle and so it was remarkably cheap to make.

I used a Smoked Porter instead of Guinness this time, and don’t see much difference in flavor. Also, the 1/3 cup amount of the beer may be a little conservative, as it makes for a very stiff mustard consistency in the end. You could go ½ cup and I don’t think this would have any negative effects, and make the product more spreadable.

Lastly, I have been experimenting with the different sweeteners in little batches as I go to use the mustard, and I find that each choice makes a noticeable and significant difference. Of course, the honey makes it taste like a commercial “honey mustard” although this has a much more robust base, and the honey isn’t as cloying as in the commercial preparations. Using black strap molasses, makes this an entirely different product, and may not suit all tastes. I mix about a tablespoon of the base mustard and the desired sweetener in a tiny prep bowl each time I try a variation, so if I don’t like it, I haven’t ruined the whole batch. Enjoy!